ATQ BlogPoll: Week Six
Here's the new BlogPoll, and things are starting to sort themselves out a bit. Those of you who were freaking out that I could have Florida in the teens? I told you if they kept winning that things would take care of themsevles and, look out at no. 2. Alabama clearly has the better resume at this point, but its hard to argue with the Gators being right back up there after taking care of business in Death Valley.
Virginia Tech (Miami, Nebraska) and Miami (Georgia Tech), are one loss ACC teams with good wins and losses against really good teams, enough so that the strength of their resumes put them above undefeateds Iowa, Cincinnati, and Boise State. In the cases of Iowa (Penn St., Arizona, Michigan) and Cincinnati (Oregon State, Rutgers), they have multiple wins against good but not spectacular BCS teams, Iowa clearly the better resume of the two. Boise falls a notch below because, while they have beaten a fantastic Oregon team, they have played St. Mary's Junior High for Girls in every game since.
Next up is Oregon and SC, both with similar resumes. Oregon has looked a bit better against Cal and WSU, while Boise is a much better loss than Washington. That explains Oregon above USC.
LSU checks in at 10th. Losing to Florida isn't bad, and they have tow decent road wins at Washington and Georgia. Texas is 11th because, other than a mediocre Texas Tech team, they also haven't played anyone. And, with the way Oklahoma's resume looks so far, I'm not sure how much winning the Red River Shootout this weekend is going to help them.
There's my top ten, most of the rest of the ballot is splitting hairs. USF and Kansas are so low because they haven't played anyone yet. Penn State and Oklahoma are unranked because they've lost to the only teams with pulses that they have played. I coudln't decide whether to put Arkansas or Oregon State as my two loss team, as both have virtually identical resumes. I probably should have put them both but wanted to give the 25 spot to Idaho. Not because they have a resume really deserving or that I think they are one of the 25 best teams, but just to give a little recognition to the Vandals being 5-1. Not that they have really beaten a quality team, but for Idaho to be 5-1 against anybody given their history this decade is a pretty amazing statistic. Now if they can just find a way to beat Boise State.
PS--Don't worry about the delta. I forgot to submit my ballot last week.
![]() |
||
| Rank | Team | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Alabama | |
| 2 | Florida | |
| 3 | Virginia Tech | |
| 4 | Miami (Florida) | |
| 5 | Iowa | |
| 6 | Cincinnati | |
| 7 | Boise State | |
| 8 | Oregon | |
| 9 | Southern Cal | |
| 10 | LSU | |
| 11 | Texas | |
| 12 | Georgia Tech | |
| 13 | TCU | |
| 14 | Ohio State | |
| 15 | South Carolina | |
| 16 | Houston | |
| 17 | Nebraska | |
| 18 | Kansas | |
| 19 | South Florida | |
| 20 | Oklahoma State | |
| 21 | Auburn | |
| 22 | Wisconsin | |
| 23 | Notre Dame | |
| 24 | Arkansas | |
| 25 | Idaho | |
11 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I like it
I’m getting used to this “resume” thing. The only quibble I have is Arkansas-Auburn. Yeah, I know Auburn has only one loss, but Arkansas lost to two pretty good teams and has a couple quality wins while Auburn hasn’t beaten anyone. They’re pretty close, but I’d at least move Arkansas up to 23 and Auburn down to 24.
I like your rationale on the top ten.
I feel the need, the need...for speed!
Haha! Yeah Vandals!!!
A much needed bye week; and two whole weeks to focus the inner hatred of UW even moreso than normal.
Locker...Welcome to my profile, You will be formally introduced by Juju at a later date, 10/23 to be more specific!
iowa
I think this team is too high in every poll. They beat a Penn st team they beat last year and a Penn st team that is overrated. They beat, Northern Iowa BY ONE, Arkansas St BY THREE, and Michigan BY TWO. If they were a top 5 team they would blow out these teams.
wants to challenge the definitions of sin and search the world for lovers of ultimate beauty but never settle in.
This is one of those “resume” things that I had trouble grasping at first too. If Iowa is really not that good, they’ll not only get pounded by tOSU, but they’ll lose to at least one of the other good-not-great Big 10 teams (Minnesota or Wisconsin, most likely). In other words, we have to give them credit NOW for putting wins on the board, but they’re certainly ripe for a fall later on this season.
If we were ranking on ability, Iowa would get dropped a few spots.
I feel the need, the need...for speed!
what is their resume though?
you think beating penn st and barely beating ark st, mich, and n iowa is a good resume? I think if you are basing this on resume it is not only how many wins you have but what those wins are like.
wants to challenge the definitions of sin and search the world for lovers of ultimate beauty but never settle in.
by joffthedeckk on Oct 14, 2009 11:48 AM PDT up reply actions
Those are decent wins
Penn St. is still a quality team, plus they beat them on the road. Michigan is obviously improved, although still inconsistent. The other wins are pretty much crap, but two quality wins is more than a lot of teams have at this point (Florida, for example, has one, but it was a pretty big one).
I feel the need, the need...for speed!
The bottom line is...
Iowa has played decent teams, and is undefeated. I don’t think they are any good myself either, but until they lose…They deserve to be ranked high
A much needed bye week; and two whole weeks to focus the inner hatred of UW even moreso than normal.
Locker...Welcome to my profile, You will be formally introduced by Juju at a later date, 10/23 to be more specific!
A little late for this week...
But BSU needs to drop significantly next week. The only thing they have going for them right now is their win against us. Beyond that, they have looked poor against weak competition. They barely beat Tulsa, who Oklahoma spanked 45-0 without Bradford, and had troubles with UC Davis. Also, they didn’t even look that good against us, and as poorly as the Ducks played, they were still in the game midway through the 4th.
With BSU’s strength of schedule, they need to be dominating these teams, and they aren’t.
--AddictedToQuack, SBNation's Oregon Ducks blog
I think they may suffer an upset this season in the mighty WAC conference play
If they perform like they have been as of late
A much needed bye week; and two whole weeks to focus the inner hatred of UW even moreso than normal.
Locker...Welcome to my profile, You will be formally introduced by Juju at a later date, 10/23 to be more specific!

by 



















